Opposing Views: Assisted Dying – Mercy or Murder? | Dr. Ellen Wiebe & Dr. Mark Pickering

EP 182The Mikhaila Peterson PodcastPublished February 22, 2023Solo episode

In this episode of the Opposing Views series, I spoke with Dr. Ellen Wiebe and Dr. Mark Pickering about the ethics and legalities behind medical assistance in dying (MAID). We talked about the arguments for and against making MAID available, which demographics are asking for it, the potential risks, and which countries allow it. Dr. Ellen Wiebe is a clinical professor in the Department of Family Practice at the University of British Columbia. After 30 years of full-service family practice, she now restricts her practice to women’s health and assisted death. Dr.

Chapters

  1. 0:00Intro
  2. 0:43Dr. Ellen Wiebe Intro and Background
  3. 1:49Legislation Allowing Assisted Death in Canada
  4. 8:42Why Dr. Wiebe Enjoys Her Work
  5. 11:33Which Demographics Choose Assisted Death and Why
  6. 13:59Mental Illness and Assisted Death
  7. 18:02Conditions for Assisted Death
  8. 20:43Timeline of Legalities for Assisted Death
  9. 27:00Can Doctors Suggest Assisted Death?
  10. 28:20Diagnosis and Human Rights
  11. 33:42Dr. Mark Pickering Intro and Background
  12. 34:30What Is Medical Assisted Dying?
  13. 37:05What Is Currently Legal in the UK?
  14. 39:12Euthanasia vs. Assisted Dying
  15. 40:57The Argument Against Assisted Death
  16. 44:42Chronic Pain and the Slippery Slope
  17. 48:44What About Switzerland, Belgium and Holland?
  18. 53:09Assisted Death And Dementia
  19. 55:56Organ Donation in Canada
  20. 57:47Mental Illness as a Condition for Assisted Death
  21. 1:01:23The Push Back Against Assisted Death
  22. 1:04:54How Does Faith Impact This Discussion?

Transcript

Intro

Dr. Ellen Wiebe Intro and Background

Legislation Allowing Assisted Death in Canada

Why Dr. Wiebe Enjoys Her Work

Which Demographics Choose Assisted Death and Why

Mental Illness and Assisted Death

Conditions for Assisted Death

Timeline of Legalities for Assisted Death

Can Doctors Suggest Assisted Death?

Diagnosis and Human Rights

Dr. Mark Pickering Intro and Background

What Is Medical Assisted Dying?

Euthanasia vs. Assisted Dying

The Argument Against Assisted Death

Chronic Pain and the Slippery Slope

What About Switzerland, Belgium and Holland?

Assisted Death And Dementia

Organ Donation in Canada

Mental Illness as a Condition for Assisted Death

The Push Back Against Assisted Death

How Does Faith Impact This Discussion?